Boiler vs. Furnace: Which Should Heat My Home?

  • February 17, 2021

When it comes to keeping your home warm and comfortable, the choice between furnace or boiler installation for your Toronto home is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your heating experience, energy bills, and environmental footprint. 

Knowing the inner workings of boilers and furnaces, and comparing them across key factors, will help you make an informed decision about the best heating solution for your home.

Contact Hoerner Today!

How Does A Boiler Heat My Home?

A boiler is a heating system that uses water or steam to distribute warmth throughout your home. Here’s a simplified breakdown of how it operates:

  • Water/Steam Generation: Boilers heat water or generate steam using electricity, oil, gas, or other fuel sources.
  • Distribution: The hot water or steam is circulated through pipes to cast iron radiators, baseboard radiators, or radiant flooring systems.
  • Radiant Heat: Radiators or other heat emitters release the heat into the surrounding air, warming the space.
  • Return: Cooled water returns to the boiler, and the cycle repeats.

How Does A Furnace Heat My Home?

Furnaces, on the other hand, are forced-air systems that distribute hot air throughout the home. Furnaces blow hot air through a system of ducts and vents. Here’s a simplified overview of how a furnace heats air:

  • Combustion or Electric Resistance: In a gas furnace, natural gas is ignited, producing a flame that heats a heat exchanger. In an electric furnace, heating elements generate warmth.
  • Air Circulation: A blower fan pushes air over the heated heat exchanger or elements.
  • Distribution: The warmed air is then circulated through the home’s duct system.
  • Vents and Registers: Vents and registers release the hot air into rooms, providing a consistent and even heating experience.

Boiler Vs. Furnace Showdown:

How Much Do They Cost?

When considering the cost of a furnace vs boiler, both systems come with their own financial considerations. 

A boiler heating system typically involves a higher upfront cost compared to furnaces. The installation of a boiler can be more complex, impacting initial expenses. However, it’s essential to note that boiler systems may offer potential long-term savings on energy bills due to their efficiency.

On the other hand, furnaces generally come with lower upfront costs, making them a more cost-effective choice for homeowners on a budget. The installation process for furnaces is often simpler, reducing initial expenses. However, the potentially higher long-term energy bills should be factored into the overall cost analysis.

Will They Heat My Home Well?

Boilers vs furnaces have distinct characteristics in terms of heating effectiveness. 

Boilers provide consistent and even heating, making them ideal for homes with radiant heating systems (such as cast iron radiators or radiant flooring systems). The radiant heat emitted from radiators or other heat emitters ensures a comfortable and uniform temperature throughout the home. However, boiler systems may take longer to heat the entire home due to the nature of their operation.

Furnaces, on the other hand, are known for quick and efficient heating. The forced-air systems distribute heated air rapidly, making furnaces suitable for homes with ductwork. However, there is a potential for uneven heating in certain cases, as the warm air is dispersed through vents and registers.

How Long Do They Last?

The lifespan of a boiler vs furnace is a critical factor in long-term planning and cost considerations. 

Boilers typically have a lifespan of 15 to 30 years with proper maintenance. Regular maintenance, including checks for leaks, system pressure, and water quality, can contribute to the longevity and reduce boiler repairs.

Gas furnaces generally last between 15 and 30 years, while electric furnaces often have a lifespan of 20 to 30 years. Routine maintenance, including filter replacement and inspections of the combustion system, is essential to ensure the furnace operates efficiently throughout its lifespan.

Are They Energy Efficient?

Energy efficiency is a crucial aspect of any furnace vs boiler debate, impacting both operational costs and environmental considerations. Luckily, both systems have come a long way in the quest to increase energy efficiency.

Boilers are renowned for their high efficiency, especially in radiant heating systems. The zoned heating capabilities of boilers allow for precise control over individual areas of the home, contributing to an energy efficient system.

Furnaces are also designed to be energy efficient, although the degree of efficiency can vary. Check for the ENERGY STAR logo when buying a furnace. The environmental impact depends on the energy source—whether gas or electricity. However, duct losses in a forced-air system may reduce the overall efficiency of a furnace.

How Do They Impact My Carbon Footprint?

Environmental consciousness has become increasingly important in home heating decisions, and both furnaces and boilers offer energy efficient models. 

Boilers have a lower carbon footprint, especially when equipped with modern, efficient models. Steam boilers operate in a closed system, leading to less wasted energy and heat. Radiant floor systems, commonly associated with boilers, use less energy and contribute to a more sustainable home heating solution.

Furnaces, depending on the energy source, can have varying impacts on the environment. The carbon footprint is influenced by factors such as the type of fuel used and the efficiency of the system. Natural gas furnaces heat air in a combustion chamber, and as a result there are carbon dioxide emissions. Duct losses too may offset some of the potential energy savings, impacting the overall environmental footprint.

Do I Need To Worry About Sizing?

Proper sizing of a heating system is crucial for optimal efficiency and even heating throughout the home. 

Boilers require careful sizing to ensure efficient operation and consistent warmth. Zoned heating, a feature often associated with boilers, allows for more precise control over individual areas, enhancing the overall sizing flexibility.

Furnaces also demand proper sizing to ensure efficient performance and comfort. Ensuring the furnace is appropriately sized for the home’s square footage is essential. While furnaces may require additional considerations for even heating, proper sizing is a critical factor for both systems.

Do They Need Annual Maintenance?

Regular maintenance is key to the longevity and efficiency of any furnace or boiler system. 

Boilers require annual maintenance, including checks for leaks, system pressure, and water quality. Routine inspections and upkeep contribute to the reliable and extended operation of the boiler.

Furnaces also demand regular maintenance to ensure optimal performance. This includes tasks such as filter replacement and inspections of the combustion system. Annual maintenance is essential for both boilers and furnaces to address potential issues, enhance efficiency, and promote longevity.

Which One Is Safer?

Safety is a paramount consideration in choosing a heating system for your home. Boilers are generally considered safe. Since there is no combustion occurring within living spaces, the risk of carbon monoxide leaks is minimized. Boilers emit heat through the distribution of water or steam, providing a safe and controlled heating environment.

Furnaces, particularly those relying on combustion for heat generation, require proper ventilation to ensure safety. While modern furnaces are equipped with advanced safety features, the potential risk of carbon monoxide leaks exists if the system is not adequately maintained. Proper installation and regular inspections are crucial to the safe operation of a furnace.

Let Hoerner Help with Heat Your Home

In the ultimate decision between a boiler and a furnace, homeowners must weigh these factors against their specific needs, budget constraints, and long-term goals. Whether you prioritize even heating, upfront costs, or environmental impact, Hoerner can empower you with the knowledge needed to make an informed choice for a warm, efficient, and safe home. We install the best boiler brands such as NTI BoilersViessmann Boilers and IBC Boilers

Book online with us today